I'm curious, what is the benefit to using MakeMKV vs CloneBD for step 2? Could you not just use CloneBD for both steps?Įdit: Assuming you don't care about Dolby Vision. I'm having the same issues with ac3 with the Blu Ray versions of the Star Wars discs as well. \eac3to "\0800.mpls" 3: 0800_tre.eac3 -no2ndpassĥ) Mux Video and subtitles from step 2 with audio from steps 3 and 4 with MkvToolNix (I doesn't handle TrueHD tracks correctly though.) When I look at the disc with MakeMKV (GUI) on my Mac, those two playlists show the exact same duration, but differ as follows: 00800.MPLS -> Segment Map 800 -> 20 Chapters -> 1:25:54 -> 18GB. So, process the correct playlist using CloneBD, saving to mkv with untouched audio track.Ĥ) For the AC3 and EAC3 tracks, eac3to correctly handles the repeated frames, but only if you disable the second pass when processing. It's occurring on the DD+ and standard Dolby Ac3 tracks as well.Ĭurrent workarounds for getting correct results:Ģ) Process correct playlist using Makemkv to extract video and subtitle streams to mkv.ģ) For TrueHD Atmos, I've found that CloneBD correctly handles the repeated frames, however, you can't rip the interleaved ac3 track using it. You can convert MKV to MP4, MOV, MP3, etc. Usually when its a few short ones tagged on at the end its to thank an outside team post credits. This issue is not limited to the TrueHD Atmos tracks either. MKV files are videos saved in the Matroska container format. If you make a decrypted backup you can go to Save Location Movie TitleBDMVSTREAM and find the files referenced and see what they are for yourself. The overall file length is correct, and the sync is only off on alternating segments by one audio frame, but there are pops in the audio at every segment boundary, due to repeats or missing frames. I've gone through and checked at each and every segment boundary, and have notice that Makemkv seems to alternate between not deleting the repeated audio frame at the first segment boundary, and then deleting both repeated frames at the next boundary. I'm currently using Rogue One for testing. It looks 00259.MPLS is the correct playlist for Source Code. Then google for the movie name and the playlist number and see if there are any hits. I posted in another thread regarding ATMOS audio that MakeMKV is not deleting overlapping audio frames correctly at the segment boundaries for any of the Star Wars films I've tried ripping from UHD. The first one on the list is the right one 99 of the time.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Details
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |